Missed Opportunities and Excuses Overshadow England’s Defeat to All Blacks
England’s 24-22 defeat to the All Blacks at Twickenham was overshadowed by an apparent “excuse culture” surrounding the national team. Head coach Steve Borthwick was quick to explain away the loss, while the official England Rugby account posted a controversial message about “learning” rather than acknowledging the defeat.
The post-match tone from Borthwick felt formulaic, as he highlighted the All Blacks’ greater experience and time together as factors in the result. However, the England team selection and substitutions raised questions, with Marcus Smith’s removal proving particularly contentious.
In truth, the All Blacks were there for the taking, with uncharacteristic handling errors and indiscipline. England failed to capitalize, with their only try coming from a Smith interception. The decision to bring off the in-form fly-half left many supporters frustrated, with the team unable to close out a game they should have won.
Maro Itoje’s comments prior to the match about wanting to be part of a winning England team resonated, but the side’s inability to see out close encounters against top opposition is becoming a worrying trend. Four defeats in their last five Tests is unacceptable for a team with aspirations of challenging the world’s best.
Borthwick must now find a way to instill a more ruthless winning mentality in his players, rather than relying on the narrative of “learning experiences.” With Australia and South Africa looming, England cannot afford more moral victories or excuses.
The broadcasting of referee Angus Gardner’s deliberations was a positive innovation, providing spectators with greater insight into the complex decision-making process. However, the continued use of “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot” by England fans remains a divisive issue, with calls for a more stirring anthem like “Jerusalem” to better reflect the team’s ambitions.
🔗 Source
